Business Solutions
SureCritic / Makes / Subaru / Forester / 2011

2011 Subaru Forester

Average Score

Overall Rating 4.3/5Overall Rating 4.3/5Overall Rating 4.3/5Overall Rating 4.3/5Overall Rating 4.3/5
4.3
(48 Reviews)
43%
Write a Review
Category Summary
(Avg. out of 10)
    Value
  • Features
  • Build Quality
  • Fun
  • Reliability
  • Performance
  • Exterior
  • Comfort
  • Interior
  • Styling

Reviews

Overall Rating 4.3/5Overall Rating 4.3/5Overall Rating 4.3/5Overall Rating 4.3/5Overall Rating 4.3/5
4.3
(48 Reviews)
Write a Review

Reviews

MH
gravatar
MARK H.
2011 Subaru Forester
verified customer Verified Owner
Overall Rating 1.0/5Overall Rating 1.0/5Overall Rating 1.0/5Overall Rating 1.0/5Overall Rating 1.0/5
01/31/2019
Verified Review

New engine leaking oil

Our first engine burned oil and Subaru replaced it at 50,000 miles. The new engine started leaking oil at 75,000 or so. The rear main seal is leaking and that is a major problem that will be expensive to fix. First and last Subaru for me!
Recommended
    Value
  • Build Quality
  • Reliability
  • Exterior
  • Interior
  • Features
  • Fun
  • Performance
  • Comfort
  • Styling
CG
gravatar
CHRIS G.
2011 Subaru Forester
verified customer Verified Owner
Overall Rating 1.0/5Overall Rating 1.0/5Overall Rating 1.0/5Overall Rating 1.0/5Overall Rating 1.0/5
11/28/2019
Verified Review

Sure it's great... On my third engine

So I guess Subaru dad a recall and a class action lawsuit about the 2011 Forester which no one told me about. Despite the fact that while it was under warranty the first engine blew. They assured me at GO Subaru on Arapahoe Rd in Greenwood Village Colorado, that it was a fluke, a one in a million occurrence. They didn't notify me of the class action lawsuit and neither did Subaru. Last year my engine blew again. It wasn't under warranty. I took it to a local Subaru mechanic who was all too familiar with the problem. He got me a new engine (not a 2011 boxter engineer) and did great work. It was 6k out the door. Subaru is an awful untrustworthy business that makes pretty good cars. But for all my and wife's next cars and for my four kids.. Pretty sure Subaru will never see another dime. Which is a shame. Two generations and six cars they will never sell. By the way never do business with the Subaru dealer on Arapahoe..I think they are Auto Nation now... Pikers, cheats and liars all of them
Recommended
    Value
  • Build Quality
  • Reliability
  • Exterior
  • Interior
  • Features
  • Fun
  • Performance
  • Comfort
  • Styling
RR
gravatar
Roger R.
2011 Subaru Forester
Overall Rating 1.0/5Overall Rating 1.0/5Overall Rating 1.0/5Overall Rating 1.0/5Overall Rating 1.0/5
05/05/2020

What a high maintenance SUV! BUYER BEWARE!!

I HAVE NEVER HAD A VEHICLE THAT HAS TO BE CONSTANTLY WATCHED AND MAINTAINED AS THIS ONE, 2 QTS / 1000 MILES, RUNS ROUGH, QUITS, THROWS CODES FOR EVERYTHING, PLUGS/COIL FAULTS, NOW IT SITS IN MY DRIVEWAY WILL NOT START WILL NOT GIVE ANY CODES. NOW ILL HAVE TO GET IT TO A SHOP FOR AREAL SCANNER TO TROUBLESHOOT. IT'S TO BAD, it drives nice, feels good going down the road and highway, but SUBARU really screwed up with all the damn sensors! Being a technician I see all kinds of things and how to troubleshoot, but Subaru built this so unless you have a $2000+ troubleshooting/code analyzer diagnostic computer your going to be SOL. I'm pulling sensors out, checking them with a OHM meter, shooting wires, reading the wiring diagrams and I'm against a intermittent fault. So clearly without a way to get into the ECU, your dead in the water. So this is the reason for the one star. Maybe Subaru will start to include a life time of computer diagnostic troubleshooting in their warranty and a couple hand full of sensors, wondering if Yugo built this one. AVOID the 2009-2013, junk engines and SOA will leave you holding the bag. The real sad thing is they are built very well, but the electrical issues will screw you up and cost. And the oil using engine YOU MUST STAY AHEAD OF or it will eat itself up on your dime.
Recommended
    Value
  • Build Quality
  • Reliability
  • Exterior
  • Interior
  • Features
  • Fun
  • Performance
  • Comfort
  • Styling
HH
gravatar
Hamid H.
2011 Subaru Forester
Overall Rating 2.0/5Overall Rating 2.0/5Overall Rating 2.0/5Overall Rating 2.0/5Overall Rating 2.0/5
12/18/2021

Burns Oil, Leaks Oil, Good AWD

I bought my 2011 Subaru brand new. First oil change at 3k I was shocked to find only 3 Qts of oil coming out of engine. Turns out it badly burns oil (about 1qt / 1000 miles). It also leaks a lot of oil from Cam Carriers and front timing chain cover. All are costly repairs. This is my 1st and last Subaru. Only good thing about it is the AWD. With snow tires on, it is a beast.
Recommended
    Value
  • Build Quality
  • Reliability
  • Exterior
  • Interior
  • Features
  • Fun
  • Performance
  • Comfort
  • Styling
RM
gravatar
Rich M.
2011 Subaru Forester
Overall Rating 3.0/5Overall Rating 3.0/5Overall Rating 3.0/5Overall Rating 3.0/5Overall Rating 3.0/5
09/13/2016

Meh

My father's CRV which is two years older gets way better MPG, has had far less issues, and rides much better - and the CRV has double the miles. This is the first car my wife and I purchased new. Thought it would be an awesome experience but it has been "meh." In terms of reliability - the only mechanical issue we have had in 6 yrs and 51k miles is a cam shaft seal. Had that not been under warranty it would have hurt. Also the shocks went bad around 20k which was very surprising. Ever get stuck? Nope! Best AWD available under $50k. But with the average 18 MPG and bad ride quality, despite a really nice interior and great amenities this car gets a lackluster overall rating. Oh, almost forgot, the transmission shudders badly. Feels like TCC lockup issue. Not looking forward to that repair. A far cry from what I would expect from Motor Trend's 2009 Car of the Year winner
Recommended
    Value
  • Build Quality
  • Reliability
  • Exterior
  • Interior
  • Features
  • Fun
  • Performance
  • Comfort
  • Styling
LP
gravatar
Liz P.
2011 Subaru Forester
verified customer Verified Owner
Overall Rating 3.0/5Overall Rating 3.0/5Overall Rating 3.0/5Overall Rating 3.0/5Overall Rating 3.0/5
03/30/2019
Verified Review

My car

Love my Subaru Forestet, but it burns oil really bad. Received an oil change and 3000 miles later no oil left which is not good. This is the only complaint I have on the vehicle. It would be nice to get better gas mileage and I would get another one if the oil problem gets fixed.
Recommended
    Value
  • Build Quality
  • Reliability
  • Exterior
  • Interior
  • Features
  • Fun
  • Performance
  • Comfort
  • Styling
RW
gravatar
ROBERT W.
2011 Subaru Forester
verified customer Verified Owner
Overall Rating 3.0/5Overall Rating 3.0/5Overall Rating 3.0/5Overall Rating 3.0/5Overall Rating 3.0/5
09/04/2019
Verified Review

Built-in Oil Leak

When buying a new car the customer must always assume that the unit was constructed without flaws. Unfortunately, some 2011 Foresters were manufactured with inadequate timing cover oil seals. This defect did not show up until about 50,000 miles. The owner has decided to let it leak. In discussing this problem with my previous mechanic I inquired if such an oil leak might contribute to an engine fire. We both agreed that if a fire were to break out I should stop the car, unfasten the seat belts and exit the vehicle. Unfortunately, this manufacturing defect is one which Subaru prefers not to address. The service writer exhibited a wry smile when I pointed out that the inspection report included the timing cover oil leak. Will I buy another Subaru?
Recommended
    Value
  • Build Quality
  • Reliability
  • Exterior
  • Interior
  • Features
  • Fun
  • Performance
  • Comfort
  • Styling
JD
gravatar
JILLIAN D.
2011 Subaru Forester
verified customer Verified Owner
Overall Rating 3.0/5Overall Rating 3.0/5Overall Rating 3.0/5Overall Rating 3.0/5Overall Rating 3.0/5
01/26/2021
Verified Review

Subaru Forester

Great for taking to trails, skiing, and car camping. Unreliable engine.
Recommended
    Value
  • Build Quality
  • Reliability
  • Exterior
  • Interior
  • Features
  • Fun
  • Performance
  • Comfort
  • Styling
JL
gravatar
JUDITH L.
2011 Subaru Forester
Overall Rating 4.0/5Overall Rating 4.0/5Overall Rating 4.0/5Overall Rating 4.0/5Overall Rating 4.0/5
05/28/2015

I LOVE my Forester!

That's pretty much it.
Recommended
    Value
  • Build Quality
  • Reliability
  • Exterior
  • Interior
  • Features
  • Fun
  • Performance
  • Comfort
  • Styling
TF
gravatar
TONY F.
2011 Subaru Forester
Overall Rating 4.0/5Overall Rating 4.0/5Overall Rating 4.0/5Overall Rating 4.0/5Overall Rating 4.0/5
03/29/2017

dependable

Vehicle has been reliable and dependable.
Recommended
    Value
  • Build Quality
  • Reliability
  • Exterior
  • Interior
  • Features
  • Fun
  • Performance
  • Comfort
  • Styling
TF
gravatar
TONY F.
2011 Subaru Forester
verified customer Verified Owner
Overall Rating 4.0/5Overall Rating 4.0/5Overall Rating 4.0/5Overall Rating 4.0/5Overall Rating 4.0/5
02/28/2018
Verified Review

reliable with minimal repairs or upkeep

reliable with minimal repairs or upkeep quality interior with seats and carpets. full sun roof that operates nicely. foot room lacking between brake and gas pedals. good pickup and speed. Able to tow motorcycle and trailer easily.
Recommended
    Value
  • Build Quality
  • Reliability
  • Exterior
  • Interior
  • Features
  • Fun
  • Performance
  • Comfort
  • Styling
NR
gravatar
NASON R.
2011 Subaru Forester
verified customer Verified Owner
Overall Rating 4.0/5Overall Rating 4.0/5Overall Rating 4.0/5Overall Rating 4.0/5Overall Rating 4.0/5
03/11/2018
Verified Review

2011 Forester

Have a 2011 Forester. Nice vehicle. Smooth ride. Comfortable. Haven't had any problems with it. A few less bells and whistles than some other cars in the same space, but we had a Subaru before and went with it again. Wish it got better gas mileage, though. Averages low 20's.
Recommended
    Value
  • Build Quality
  • Reliability
  • Exterior
  • Interior
  • Features
  • Fun
  • Performance
  • Comfort
  • Styling
JB
gravatar
JAMES B.
2011 Subaru Forester
verified customer Verified Owner
Overall Rating 4.0/5Overall Rating 4.0/5Overall Rating 4.0/5Overall Rating 4.0/5Overall Rating 4.0/5
04/02/2019
Verified Review

2019 Forester

I was given the new Forester as a loaner while myCar was having recall work done. I liked that the car is a little bigger than our Forester. It drove quite a bit the same as or 2010,however, I didn’t like the roadway sensors-they seemed to be beeping quite a lot, and distracting....The heated seats are not a feature I would add to a new car...also, really don’t like the “moon” roof...
Recommended
    Value
  • Build Quality
  • Reliability
  • Exterior
  • Interior
  • Features
  • Fun
  • Performance
  • Comfort
  • Styling
BC
gravatar
Bruce C.
2011 Subaru Forester
verified customer Verified Owner
Overall Rating 4.0/5Overall Rating 4.0/5Overall Rating 4.0/5Overall Rating 4.0/5Overall Rating 4.0/5
09/19/2019
Verified Review

An example of Nate’s picky side

Lol it was purchased from Nate’s long enough ago its loan is paid off. It runs great as all there regular used cars seem to. I am suspicious that it may result from their willingness to repair replace what’s wrong before you see it. Again they stand behind what they do and sell.
Recommended
    Value
  • Build Quality
  • Reliability
  • Exterior
  • Interior
  • Features
  • Fun
  • Performance
  • Comfort
  • Styling
LA
gravatar
Lisa A.
2011 Subaru Forester
verified customer Verified Owner
Overall Rating 4.0/5Overall Rating 4.0/5Overall Rating 4.0/5Overall Rating 4.0/5Overall Rating 4.0/5
02/20/2020
Verified Review

Great car, except for the oil issue...

I want to love my Forester, and I do, for the most part. But, the constant need to to "top off" the oil between changes is annoying and expensive. The car drives great, gets me through all kinds of ice and snow, and it feels safe.
Recommended
    Value
  • Build Quality
  • Reliability
  • Exterior
  • Interior
  • Features
  • Fun
  • Performance
  • Comfort
  • Styling
LW
gravatar
Leon W.
2011 Subaru Forester
verified customer Verified Owner
Overall Rating 4.0/5Overall Rating 4.0/5Overall Rating 4.0/5Overall Rating 4.0/5Overall Rating 4.0/5
04/01/2020
Verified Review

Good vehicle, burns a lot of oil

I have enjoyed my Forester. It has a known problem with burning oil excessively. It burns 1 quart every 500 miles. I’ve been dealing with this issue for the last 50,000 miles. While this is a pain, I’d rather spend $6 for a quart of oil periodically that spend the money for a new car. Despite this issue, the car has run reliably for 156,000 miles. I plan to drive it for another 100,000 with the support of the Red Ridge guys!!
Recommended
    Value
  • Build Quality
  • Reliability
  • Exterior
  • Interior
  • Features
  • Fun
  • Performance
  • Comfort
  • Styling
KK
gravatar
Kathy K.
2011 Subaru Forester
verified customer Verified Owner
Overall Rating 4.0/5Overall Rating 4.0/5Overall Rating 4.0/5Overall Rating 4.0/5Overall Rating 4.0/5
04/07/2020
Verified Review

Loud interior. Hard to hear phone conversation on Bluetooth.

Poor gas mileage-All wheel drive I was told after buying. Car fits me well, 5’2” wahine. Has held up well. Easy to drive. Was thinking of 2019 CRV for more trunk and interior space. Decided it might be too big for me? Subaru has been very reliable. Overall it’s been a good car.
Recommended
    Value
  • Build Quality
  • Reliability
  • Exterior
  • Interior
  • Features
  • Fun
  • Performance
  • Comfort
  • Styling
KC
gravatar
Kathy C.
2011 Subaru Forester
verified customer Verified Owner
Overall Rating 4.0/5Overall Rating 4.0/5Overall Rating 4.0/5Overall Rating 4.0/5Overall Rating 4.0/5
05/18/2020
Verified Review

Subaru Forester 2011

My 2011 Subaru Forester has been a very reliable car. For the price, it is worth every penny, especially since Subaru is highly rated for safety. In hindsight I wish I had bought the turbo version because I prefer faster acceleration. Sometimes it doesn’t accelerate properly. Also with no cabin insulation the interior gets much hotter than my previous vehicle. Seats aren’t padded much, so I have to use a cushion for comfort. But overall it is a great car with minor issues.
Recommended
    Value
  • Build Quality
  • Reliability
  • Exterior
  • Interior
  • Features
  • Fun
  • Performance
  • Comfort
  • Styling
MH
gravatar
MARK H.
2011 Subaru Forester
verified customer Verified Owner
Overall Rating 4.0/5Overall Rating 4.0/5Overall Rating 4.0/5Overall Rating 4.0/5Overall Rating 4.0/5
04/10/2021
Verified Review

Car had an oil use issue that was repaired but a new small oil leak started.

Overall a good vehicle that does well in the snow. Subaru repaired the original engine around 50k for excessive oil consumption under warranty. After that new leaks occurred and it seems like this model year may not be up to the standard for them. Current mileage is 171k and still is running strong minus the small oil leak after most of the other leaks were repaired.
Recommended
    Value
  • Build Quality
  • Reliability
  • Exterior
  • Interior
  • Features
  • Fun
  • Performance
  • Comfort
  • Styling
HS
Heidi S.
2011 Subaru Forester
verified customer Verified Owner
Overall Rating 4.0/5Overall Rating 4.0/5Overall Rating 4.0/5Overall Rating 4.0/5Overall Rating 4.0/5
07/15/2021
Verified Review

Used Forester2011

Overall, I love my Forester! I bought it used with fairly low mileage. It’s served me pretty well. I have discovered that it burns oil, which apparently was an issue with this particular model and year. It’s comfortable and easy to drive. No blind spots as with a sedan. I love my Subaru’s! This one just may be a lemon!
Recommended
    Value
  • Build Quality
  • Reliability
  • Exterior
  • Interior
  • Features
  • Fun
  • Performance
  • Comfort
  • Styling
Displaying reviews 1 - 20 of 48 in total

Businesses Near You

  • European Auto Repair
  • Subaru Dealer
  • Auto Repair
100%
Franks Foreign Car
Overall Rating 5.0/5Overall Rating 5.0/5Overall Rating 5.0/5Overall Rating 5.0/5Overall Rating 5.0/5
5.0
(359 Reviews)
Appointments
  • BMW Dealer
  • Subaru Dealer
  • Auto Maintenance
100%
Integrity Autowerks Inc.
Overall Rating 5.0/5Overall Rating 5.0/5Overall Rating 5.0/5Overall Rating 5.0/5Overall Rating 5.0/5
5.0
(186 Reviews)
Appointments
  • Subaru Certified Collision Center
n/a
Auto Stiegler Collision Center
Overall Rating 4.9/5Overall Rating 4.9/5Overall Rating 4.9/5Overall Rating 4.9/5Overall Rating 4.9/5
4.9
(7 Reviews)
  • Subaru Certified Collision Center
n/a
CRASH CHAMPIONS #0758 BELLINGHAM PACIFIC
Overall Rating 4.9/5Overall Rating 4.9/5Overall Rating 4.9/5Overall Rating 4.9/5Overall Rating 4.9/5
4.9
(7 Reviews)
  • Subaru Dealer
  • Used Car Dealer
  • Auto Repair
97%
Parker Subaru
Overall Rating 4.8/5Overall Rating 4.8/5Overall Rating 4.8/5Overall Rating 4.8/5Overall Rating 4.8/5
4.8
(22994 Reviews)
Overall Rating 4.5/5Overall Rating 4.5/5Overall Rating 4.5/5Overall Rating 4.5/5Overall Rating 4.5/5
4.5
(37) ReScores
  • Body Shop
  • Collision Repair
  • Subaru Certified Collision Center
n/a
Poway Valley Collision
Overall Rating 4.7/5Overall Rating 4.7/5Overall Rating 4.7/5Overall Rating 4.7/5Overall Rating 4.7/5
4.7
(7 Reviews)
  • Subaru Certified Collision Center
  • Subaru Dealer
  • Body Shop
n/a
Faulkner Collision Center of Union Boulevard
Overall Rating 4.6/5Overall Rating 4.6/5Overall Rating 4.6/5Overall Rating 4.6/5Overall Rating 4.6/5
4.6
(13 Reviews)
  • Collision Repair
  • Body Shop
  • Subaru Certified Collision Center
n/a
Continental Collision Center-Lamar
Overall Rating 4.4/5Overall Rating 4.4/5Overall Rating 4.4/5Overall Rating 4.4/5Overall Rating 4.4/5
4.4
(28 Reviews)
Attention
We use cookies to personalize content, enable certain functionality, and track site analytics for marketing purposes. You consent to our cookies if you continue to use this website.