2011 Lexus 450H
This has been a great car to drive. Having had a BMW the past 2 cars, I really didn't know what to expect with the Lexus 450H. Yes, it's a hybrid and gets 25-27mpg, but it also has enough power when you need it. It doesn't have the sportiness and drive "feel" the BMW has, but I've been very satisfied with its performance. I've put nearly 80000 miles on it in 4 years, with only normal maintenance needed. I haven't even replaced the brakes yet.
It is too pricey if bought new. I bought mine at at year old with 12000 miles on it. That made it more affordable for me.